18/07/2025 Bertus Preller Best Interests of the Child, Children, Children's Court, constitutional rights of children, Divorce, Family reunification, Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, International Travel, Parental Alienation, Relocation, Reunification, Section 28 Constitution best interests of child, child abduction risk, child welfare, child's voice, children's act, contact arrangements, cross-border custody, custody dispute, custody evaluation, custody proceedings, expert evidence, Family Advocate, family court judgment, family law South Africa, habitual residence, interim custody, international child custody, international divorce, international family law, international jurisdiction, Mirror Orders, non-Hague country, Parental Abduction, parental coaching, Parental Rights, psychological assessment, Qatar family law, relocation application, Western Cape High Court When Borders Divide Families: M.K v A.J.K (11407/2023) [2025] ZAWCHC 288 (7 July 2025) – International Child Custody and the Qatar Dilemma. Factual Background: When Divorce Proceedings Cross International Borders This matter exemplifies the complex legal and practical challenges that arise when families with established lives in foreign jurisdictions face marital breakdown.… READ MORE
13/07/2025 Bertus Preller Alter ego trust, Divorce, Res judicata divorce, Stay of execution, Vexatious litigation abuse of process, alter ego trust, attorney own client costs, civil procedure divorce, CRW v LMW 2025, divorce enforcement, divorce law precedent, divorce trust ruling, family court Cape Town, family law trusts, Le Grange J, legal costs divorce, litigation misconduct, res judicata divorce, rescission of judgment, Rule 45A, Rule 46A, security for costs, South African case law, South African divorce law, stay of execution, trust abuse divorce, trust execution divorce, vexatious litigant South Africa, vexatious litigation, vexatious Proceedings Act, Western Cape High Court, ZAWCHC 279 Lawfare in the Divorce Courts: C.R.W v L.M.W and Another (12866/2014) [2025] ZAWCHC 279 (2 July 2025) Unmasks Vexatious Litigation and Trust Abuse. The Factual Backdrop: A Relentless Legal Battle Post-Divorce The saga in C.R.W v L.M.W and Another (12866/2014) ZAWCHC 279 (2 July 2025) represents one of the most protracted and acrimonious… READ MORE
13/07/2025 Bertus Preller Best Interests of the Child, Child protection, Children, Children's Court, Conduct of Childcare Experts, constitutional rights of children, Family reunification, Foster care, Grandparents Rights, Kinship care, Parental Rights, Procedural Law, Section 28 Constitution 4 July 2025, best interests of the child South Africa, Cape Town High Court, care and contact orders, child custody South Africa, child protection, child removal South Africa, child witness protection, Children’s Act 38 of 2005, Children’s Court appeal, constitutional rights of children, Dr Astrid Martalas, ex parte court orders, family law South Africa, family reunification judgment, foster care legal challenge, High Court appeal 2025, kinship care, legal precedent family law, legal safeguards in child care, Magistrate Sipoyo judgment, no-contact order South Africa, Parental Rights, procedural fairness South Africa, psychological harm attachment, Rule of Law family matters, S.E.T and Others v Department of Justice, Section 28 Constitution, ZAWCHC 282 “Torn Apart Without Cause”: High Court Slams Children’s Court in S.E.T and Others v Department of Justice and Another (A83/2024) [2025] ZAWCHC 282 (4 July 2025). The Factual Matrix: Arrests, Allegations and the Path to Atlantis Court This matter originated in deeply troubling circumstances involving two minor children, a six-year-old girl (X) and a one-year-old boy… READ MORE
03/07/2025 Bertus Preller Customary Law, Customary marriage requirements, Customary Marriages, Marriage registration, Recognition of Customary Marriages Act, Section 8 RCMA, Traditional marriage validity accrual system, African marriage, ante-nuptial contract, civil law, civil marriage, community of property, cultural marriage, customary law, customary marriage, Deeds Office, Family Law, legal concessions, Limpopo High Court, lobola, marital property, Marriage Act, marriage certificate, marriage disputes, marriage regimes, marriage validity, matrimonial law, matrimonial regimes, Property Division, Recognition of Customary Marriage Act, Rule 33, spousal property rights, stated case, traditional marriage, wedding ceremonies When Spouses Cannot Agree on Their Marriage Regime: L.M.P v N.J.D.P (Appeal) (HCAA33/2024) [2025] ZALMPPHC 122 (19 June 2025) and the Impossibility of Concurrent Matrimonial Systems. Factual Matrix: When Spouses Disagree on Their Marriage Regime The dispute in this matter exemplifies a peculiar but increasingly common phenomenon in South African family law where spouses find themselves… READ MORE
03/07/2025 Bertus Preller Bigamy, Constitutional Court customary law, Customary Law, Customary marriage dissolution, Customary marriage requirements, Customary Marriages, First wife consent, Mayelane precedent, Polygamous marriage, Recognition of Customary Marriages Act, Recognition of Customary Marriages Act, Section 8 RCMA bigamy, civil marriage, competing marriage claims, Constitutional Court, Constitutional Rights, customary law, customary marriage, customary marriage requirements, Deputy Judge President Ratshibvumo, Divorce Decree, equality rights, estate disputes, first wife consent, human dignity, irretrievable breakdown, lobola, marriage registration, marriage validity, matrimonial property, Mayelane precedent, Mpumalanga High Court, polygamous marriage, Recognition of Customary Marriages Act, South African Family Law, subsequent marriages, traditional marriage, widow status First Wife Consent Strikes Again: Constitutional Court’s Mayelane Precedent Upheld in N.R.M v F.N and Others (943/2023) [2025] ZAMPMBHC 53 (17 June 2025). The Factual Matrix: A Tale of Two Marriages and Competing Claims The factual backdrop to this matter presents a complex web of relationships that culminated in competing claims to marital… READ MORE
03/07/2025 Bertus Preller Constitutional Court customary law, Customary Law, Customary marriage dissolution, Customary Marriages, Desertion, Lobola negotiations, Marriage registration, Netshituka principle, Recognition of Customary Marriages Act, Recognition of Customary Marriages Act, Section 8 RCMA, Traditional marriage validity Alexkor case, candidate attorneys, civil marriage nullity, civil marriage void, Constitutional Court customary law, court decree divorce, customary law South Africa, customary marriage dissolution, customary union, desertion marital home, estate administration, estate distribution, family law attorneys, family law practitioners, inheritance rights, irretrievable breakdown, judicial oversight, law students, lobola negotiations, marriage registration requirements, Netshituka principle, polygamous marriages, Recognition of Customary Marriages Act, Section 8 RCMA, spousal consent, Supreme Court appeal, traditional marriage validity Desertion Does Not Dissolve: Eastern Cape High Court Clarifies Customary Marriage Dissolution Requirements in N.N and Others v B.N and Others (3932/2024) [2025] ZAECMHC 46 (5 June 2025). Factual Matrix: A Tale of Two Marriages and Competing Claims to the Deceased Estate This case presents a complex factual scenario involving competing matrimonial claims that unfolded over several decades.… READ MORE
02/07/2025 Bertus Preller Abuse of Process, Adversarial Legal System, Costs, Divorce, Family Law Court System South Africa, Procedural Law, Procedure, Punitive Cost Orders, Rule 30A, Uniform Form Rules of Court Afrocentrics case, attorney costs orders, Bloem case, civil procedure, condonation applications, court deadlines, court rules compliance, de bonis propriis costs, Family Court, family law proceedings, Helen Suzman Foundation case, High Court Johannesburg, late filing affidavits, legal practitioner conduct, litigation management, motion proceedings, Multi-Links case, Parental Responsibilities, Procedural irregularities, procedural non-compliance, professional conduct, Rule 27, Rule 28, Rule 30A, Rule 6, South African Law, supplementary affidavits, Uniform Rules of Court When Procedure Trumps Substance: Dissecting Rule 30A Non-Compliance in N.S v A.D (2022/257) [2025] ZAGPJHC 632 (20 June 2025). Factual Background: A Tale of Procedural Non-Compliance in Family Law Proceedings The factual matrix in N.S v A.D presents a striking illustration of how procedural non-compliance can derail even the… READ MORE
02/07/2025 Bertus Preller Appeal, Divorce, Procedural Law, Procedure, Rule 42 variation application accrual system, appellate procedures, collateral attack judgments, common mistake divorce, costs follow the cause, divorce decree variation, ex tempore judgment, final judgment finality, fraudulent misrepresentation, High Court North West Division, joint estate division, judicial officers function, legal certainty principles, legal representation errors, litigation finality, marriage out of community of property, matrimonial disputes, Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984, Matrimonial Property Regime, pleadings integrity, pre-nuptial contract, procedural missteps, property division claims, Rule 42 variation application, South African Family Law, Uniform Rules of Court, Zweni case finality When Variation Applications Fail: The Limits of Rule 42 Common Mistake in K.P.M v O.L.M and Another (Reasons) (1751/2008) [2025] ZANWHC 103 (17 June 2025). The Genesis of the Dispute: A Marriage Out of Community of Property Revisited The roots of this protracted legal dispute stretch back to 7 February 1991, when the applicant and… READ MORE
02/07/2025 Bertus Preller Divorce, Divorce settlement defects, Liquidator, Procedural Law, Receiver Divorce, Recission of Divorce Orders, Settlement agreement finality, Settlement agreement interpretation, Settlement agreement variation, Settlement agreements Children's Best Interests, children's inheritance rights, community of property marriages, condonation applications, debt-free property preservation, Divorce Act section 7(8), divorce aftermath litigation, divorce settlement defects, joint estate liquidation, legal representation duties, liquidator appointment applications, matrimonial home disputes, matrimonial property trust, motion proceedings evidence, pension benefits accrual, pension fund entitlements, pension interest claims, Plascon-Evans rule, post-divorce disputes, property occupation disputes, res judicata principles, Rule 42 variation applications, settlement agreement finality, settlement agreement variation, trust beneficiaries protection, trust registration requirements, trustee appointment orders, unrepresented parties divorce Six Years Later: Defective Settlement Clause Triggers Failed Liquidation Bid in PLB v LRB (36798/2014) [2025] ZAGPPHC 600 – 4 June 2025. The Facts: A Matrimonial Home Dispute Six Years After Divorce This case concerned a post-divorce dispute that arose six years after the dissolution of marriage between PLB and LRB, who… READ MORE
29/06/2025 Bertus Preller Abuse, Bail, Coercive Control, Cultural Abuse, Digital Abuse, Domestic Violence, Domestic Violence, Financial Abuse, GBV, Harassment, Harrassment, Interim Protection Order, Neglect, Physical Abuse, Psychological Abuse, Revenge Porn, Sexual Abuse, Spiritual Abuse, Verbal Abuse bail and constitutional rights, bail family court, bail for abusers, bail procedure GBV, bail reform South Africa, child custody GBV, CPA section 60, Criminal and Related Matters Amendment Act, criminal procedure GBV, domestic abuse bail rules, domestic violence law, family law bail, family law impact bail, family lawyer GBV, GBV bail South Africa, GBV court process, GBV justice system, GBV legal changes, intimate partner violence justice, legal reform GBV, magistrate bail GBV, no police bail GBV, protection order at bail, protection orders bail, reverse onus bail, section 60(11)(c), South African criminal law, victim safety bail No Easy Bail for Abusers: How the Criminal and Related Matters Amendment Act 12 of 2021 is Reshaping GBV Justice in South Africa. Introduction South Africa continues to grapple with an epidemic of gender-based violence (GBV), with rates of femicide reported to be five times the global average. GBV – particularly domestic and… READ MORE