31/01/2024 Bertus Preller Children, Guardianship, Parental Rights best interests of the child, Child Custody, child welfare, child-focused decisions, child's wellbeing, Court Decisions, custody assessments, Custody Battles, custody disputes, custody evaluation, custody hearings, family advocacy, Family Court, family dynamics, Family Law, family law case study, family law principles, guardianship, Legal Analysis, legal challenges, legal judgments, Legal precedents, legal responsibilities, parent-child relationship, parental disputes, parental obligations, Parental Rights, parental roles, South African Law Navigating Turbulent Waters: A Case Study on Parental Rights and the Complex Dynamics of Family Law. – G.D v M.M (4809/2022) [2024] ZAGPJHC 65 (29 January 2024) INTRODUCTION The Applicant's Request: The applicant sought an order to be declared the sole holder of parental responsibilities and rights concerning guardianship and care of the minor child. This included… READ MORE
31/01/2024 Bertus Preller Child Maintenance, Children, Review Court of public opinion, Default order dispute, Fair hearing principles, high court rulings, Judge APS Nxumalo, judicial decision-making, Jurisdictional analysis, Legal argument analysis, Legal blog content, legal case study, legal interpretation, Legal precedent analysis, Legal procedural fairness, Legal remedy exclusivity, Legal review, Legal rights in divorce, Locus standi in law, Maintenance Act 1998, Maintenance court procedures, Maintenance order challenge, Procedural irregularities, Section 18 Maintenance Act, South African Family Law, South African High Court, South African legal analysis, South African Maritime Safety Authority v McKenzie, Statutory obligation interpretation, Statutory remedies, Thomas v Balepile Unraveling Justice: The Thomas v Balepile Case and South Africa’s Maintenance Law Maze. – Thomas v Balepile (61/2021; CA&R 68/23) [2024] ZANCHC 4 (26 January 2024). Introduction In a recent and significant decision, Thomas v Balepile (61/2021; CA&R 68/23) ZANCHC 4, delivered on 26 January 2024, the High Court of South Africa, Northern Cape Division, under… READ MORE
31/01/2024 Bertus Preller Children, Divorce, Parental Rights, Schooling, Views of the Child acrimonious divorce, best interests of the child, Child Custody, child custody case, child-focused litigation, child's best interest, child's schooling, Children's Welfare, Children’s Act 38 of 2005, co-parenting, conciliation in family law, Court Proceedings, Divorce, educational stability, expert reports, Family Law, judicial decision, legal dispute, legal principles, motion proceedings, parental consent, Parental Rights, psychological well-being, Redhill School, School Enrollment, South African Constitution, South African High Court, St Stithians College, upper guardian Deciphering the Best Interests: A Legal Analysis of a Child’s Schooling in Divorce – U.R v S.B and Others (2024-001357) [2024] ZAGPJHC 55 (25 January 2024) Introduction: Urgent School Enrollment Dispute In this urgent legal matter brought before the court on 11 January 2024, the core issue revolved around the schooling of a minor child amidst… READ MORE
31/01/2024 Bertus Preller Alienation, Children, Relocation C.S.S v O.R case, child custody evaluations, child custody law, child welfare in divorce, children's removal, children’s emotional welfare, children’s residency disputes, custodial parent rights, custody emergency applications, custody legal battles, emergency custody ruling, family advocate involvement, family court proceedings, family law precedents, guardianship conflict, High Court decision, legal battle for children, legal implications of child removal, minor children's best interests, non-custodial parent challenges, parental access rights, parental custody battle, parental rights in South Africa, primary residence determination, schooling concerns in custody, South African Family Law, South African High Court judgements, urgent custody dispute, urgent legal applications Urgent Custody Dispute: Analysing C.S.S v O.R (000763/2024) [2024] ZAGPPHC 37 (26 January 2024)A Pivotal Decision on Children’s Removal. Introduction The case of C.S.S v O.R (000763/2024) ZAGPPHC 37 (26 January 2024) was an urgent opposed application brought before the court on 17 January 2024. The Applicant sought the… READ MORE
28/01/2024 Bertus Preller Abuse, Coercive Control, Digital Abuse, Emotional Abuse, Financial Abuse, Harassment, Physical Abuse, Psychological Abuse, Sexual Abuse, Verbal Abuse courtroom battles in familial disputes, domestic abuse legal solutions, domestic relationship legalities, domestic violence act and siblings, domestic violence court orders, domestic violence legal consequences, domestic violence legal framework, familial violence and legal recourse, family conflict legal guidance, family court proceedings in South Africa, family dispute resolutions, family dynamics in South African law, family law and domestic violence, family law interpretation, judicial interpretation of domestic relationships, legal advice on family conflicts, legal aspects of family feuds, legal defense against familial abuse, legal dynamics in family disputes, legal protection in family violence, legal response to domestic abuse, legal strategies against domestic abuse, navigating domestic violence protection, protective orders in family law, sibling relationship laws, South Africa domestic abuse laws, South African domestic violence legislation, understanding domestic violence statutes, understanding family law in SA Family Feuds Under the Law: Decoding Domestic Violence and Legal Protections in South Africa. – J.G v A.N (A3132/2021) [2024] ZAGPJHC 45 (26 January 2024). Background and Legal Framework Introduction to the Case In the case of J.G v A.N (A3132/2021) ZAGPJHC 45 dated 26 January 2024, an appeal was lodged against a final protection… READ MORE
27/01/2024 Bertus Preller Abuse, Adultery, Coercive Control, Costs, Divorce, Emotional Abuse, Financial Abuse, Forfeiture of Benefits, In Community of Property, Infidelity, Physical Abuse, Psychological Abuse, Reasons for Dicorce Asset Division, asset forfeiture in divorce, court evidence, court judgments, divorce case analysis, Divorce Law, divorce litigation, divorce outcomes, divorce settlements, equitable distribution, extra-marital affairs, family court dynamics, family law case studies, forfeiture, legal implications, Legal proceedings, Legal Strategy, marital breakdown, Marriage Dissolution, matrimonial conduct, matrimonial disputes, patrimonial benefits, personal conduct, physical abuse, protection orders, South African Family Law, spousal allegations, spousal behavior, spouse behavior in divorce Infidelity, Abuse, and Forfeiture: Behind the Gavel – Deciphering the Role of Personal Conduct in Divorce Outcomes in South African Courts. – M.F.B v J.B (5674/2016) [2024] ZALMPPHC 7 (24 January 2024). Background and Claims In the case presided over by Naude-Odendaal J, the Plaintiff M.F.B filed for divorce against the Defendant J.B on 23 November 2016. The Plaintiff sought a decree… READ MORE
27/01/2024 Bertus Preller Alimony, Children, Costs, Maintenance, Parental Rights, Rule 43, Rule 43 Cost Contributions, Spousal Maintenance acrimonious divorce, Asset Division, Child Custody, child maintenance, children's act, Constitutional Rights, court judgment, Divorce, divorce litigation, divorce settlement, Family Advocate, Family Court, Family Law, family trust, financial dependence, financial disclosure, interim maintenance, Legal Costs, Legal Fees, Legal Representation, marital property, marital regime, matrimonial disputes, Mediation, Rule 43, Separation, South Africa, spousal support, Uniform Rules of Court Unravelling the Tangles of Divorce: A South African Rule 43 – Case Study on Interim Maintenance and Legal Costs – T.C v B.C (21300/2022) [2024] ZAGPJHC 48 (25 January 2024). Background In this case, presided over by Mahomed AJ, an application was made for interim maintenance and a contribution toward legal costs, in line with Rule 43 of the Uniform… READ MORE
25/01/2024 Bertus Preller Children, Parental Rights, Relocation 2023 court ruling, best interests of the child, child custody law, Child Relocation, child welfare, child's psychological well-being, court judgment, custody dispute, D.J.H. v A.H, divorce proceedings, Eastern Cape High Court, family advocate report, family law implications, family law judgments, family law precedent, judicial scrutiny, Legal Analysis, legal arguments, legal case review, legal precedent, legal reasoning, Parental Responsibilities, Parental Rights, relocation case study, relocation impact, relocation jurisprudence, relocation opposition, South African Family Law, South African jurisprudence Navigating the Tides of Change: The Intricacies of Child Relocation in D.J.H. v A.H (914/2023) [2023] ZAECMKHC 139, (12 December 2023). – Rugunanan J. Overview of the D.J.H. v A.H Relocation Dispute In the case D.J.H. v A.H (914/2023) ZAECMKHC 139, the Eastern Cape Division of the High Court grappled with a contentious child… READ MORE
24/01/2024 Bertus Preller Child Maintenance, Children, Maintenance Case Law Analysis, Cause of Action, Court Procedures, Court Rulings, Courtroom Tactics, Defense Strategy, Exception Handling, Exception Success, Judicial Reasoning, Legal Claims, Legal Clarification, Legal Disputes, Legal Doctrine, Legal Exceptions, Legal Framework, legal interpretation, Legal Obstructions, Legal precedents, legal principles, Legal Technicalities, Litigation Process, Litigation Strategy, Over-Technical Approach, Pleading Challenges, Pleading Sufficiency, Pleadings Assessment, Procedural Tactics, Substantive Law, Substantive Questions Navigating Parental Maintenance Obligations and Mastering Legal Exceptions: The KGANYAGO J Judgment in Context. – U.DJ v J.H.O (9169/2022) [2024] ZALMPPHC 2 (15 January 2024). Background and Plaintiff’s Claims The case involves the plaintiff and defendant, who are the parents of a child now of majority age. Following the breakdown of their relationship, the child… READ MORE
24/01/2024 Bertus Preller Adversarial Legal System, Arrears, Children, Contempt of Court, Divorce, Hostile Family Lawyers, Maintenance adversarial litigation, Amicable Solutions, child welfare, Children's Best Interests, Civil Contempt, Collaborative Resolution, Court Order Compliance, Court Order Violation, D.N.Q v P.Q case, Divorce Litigation Costs, divorce proceedings, Electricity Bill Dispute, Emotional Tensions, Family Law, Financial Disputes, Financial Strain, High Court ruling, Legal Costs, Legal Practitioners' Conduct, Legal Professional Responsibility, Legal Representation, Legal Strategy, Litigation Impact, Marital Tensions, Marumoagae AJ, matrimonial home, Mediation, Rule of Law, South African Judiciary Adversarial Litigation in Divorce and Family Law Practitioners’ Conduct: Unpacking – D.N.Q v P.Q (49090/2021) [2024] ZAGPPHC 12 (12 January 2024). Background of the Dispute The case of D.N.Q v P.Q (49090/2021) ZAGPPHC 12, presided over by Marumoagae AJ, emerged from a dispute within the context of a protracted divorce process.… READ MORE